red rule
de Volkskrant
de Volkskrant

Everyday Art

By accident not a news item that shook the world

Of course he could have had a seat next to a journalist, the young American sergeant 
R. who had been given two weeks furlough from Iraq. Or next to a politician, an 
Amnesty International staff member, a cleric, a pop musician. But he had a seat next 
to an artist, a politically committed artist.
For ten hours Penny Allen listened to R.’s  horror stories. In the 70s and 80s Allen 
was active as an independent film maker, and she later was known for her photo strips 
criticizing American society.
R. showed her pictures of his friend’s death the day before, and a film he and his 
comrades had shot of an Iraqi suicide bomber whose body was totally torn apart by 
the bomb.
At first Allen just listened, because she felt that R. needed to tell his story. 
Later because she couldn’t do anything else, because his story became her story as well, 
she began to feel responsible. They stayed in touch, R. regularly sent her packages from 
Iraq. And Allen put the photos and his stories in the only format she could think of: a 
photo strip. A strip without humor, and without the usual onomatopoeias that one sees in 
strips, like KABOOM! or CRASH!
War is Hell (the words are R.’s, who remains anonymous for security reasons) is only four 
pages. The strip was presented last year in a gallery in Portland, Oregon, and has been 
traveling the world since that day, the world of journalism and the world of art.
It appeared for instance in Mother Jones, a critical American monthly, in the French morning 
paper Líbération and in Exit Art, a politically engaged New York gallery. Those who see 
the strip are shocked. But so far it hasn’t become a news item that shook the world. Can 
war become art? Or: is it necessary that war becomes art? Would R.’s photos have been 
talked about as much if they would have had a different outlet? And: what reactions would 
the pictures from the Abu Ghraib prison have caused if not CBS but Penny Allen would have 
published them first?
In the TV-program Wintergasten Kristien Hemmerechts (Flemish author; tr.) asked writer 
Jonathan Safran Foer whether it was wise for an artist to turn recent events into literature. 
She was referring to his novel Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, that partly deals with the 
WTC attacks. Shouldn’t he have waited a little longer?
Foer didn’t understand her objections. He writes, he said, from his own view of the events, 
his vision as an artist. To wait until they’ve become history, or to research their  
authenticity - that’s not something he is interested in.
Foer’s  books however are not any less true. And sergeant R.’s story is not less real because 
he had a seat on the plane next to a visual artist instead of a journalist.

Merel Bem

Also see

(From de Volkskrant, Netherlands; January 20, 2006)

red rule